Edgerouter X - IPsec Benchmarked

As I posted last time, the MediaTek SoC (MT7621AT) in ER-X has a EIP-93 crypto engine. It has impressive performance specification. Authentec quotes 450 Kpps for 64-byte packets and 300-500 Mbit/s throughput. MediaTek quotes around 200 Mbit/s.

I found mixed results from my tests. I use AES-128/SHA1 for ESP and AES-256/SHA256 for keying. In one direction, I consistently got as high as 380 Mbit/s. In the other direction it is around 130 Mbit/s regardless how hard I tried.

My test setup is same as in my previous post. Macbook Pro is the client from "Internet" which connects to ER-X and between them is a IPsec tunnel. Iperf3 streams are sent between MBP and iMac.

Let me summarise the numbers:

IPsec throughput on ER-X with four iperf3 streams

Download means iperf3 sending data from iMac to MBP. Upload is the other way round. I found four iperf3 streams saturate the maximum throughput.

Let's focus on the 1460-byte packet size. In download direction, 377 Mbit/s is very good throughput in my opinion. It surpasses the quoted number from MediaTek and close to the 500 Mbit/s upper bound quoted by Authentec. In upload direction, relatively speaking it's a little disappointing. 128 Mbit/s is only about one third of the download throughput.

Put the numbers in perspective. A single iperf3 stream gives 244 Mbit/s in download and 127 Mbit/s in upload. More streams do not increase the throughput in upload direction at all.

Why is the upload seemingly capped at 130 Mbit/s? I have some theories but I don't have the authoritative answer. I saw all four ksoftirqd working in download but only one or two working in upload.

Will see if could get feedback from Ubiquiti or possible improvement.


Stephen Yip

Something about you know. Come and share.

comments powered by Disqus